In 2005 retail allotment favoured many small applications, and a small bid did not need a PAN. So the way to win more shares was to become thousands of applicants.
SEBI's order of 15 December 2005 on the Yes Bank IPO set out what it found:
- 6,315 demat accounts applied in the retail category.
- 6,221 of them gave the same address, and all banked with the same bank.
- On the day after allotment, the shares were moved out of these accounts to one person. SEBI described the applicants as "men of straw".
6,221 of 6,315 accounts gave one address
SEBI widened its investigation to IPOs from 2003 to 2005. On 27 April 2006 it barred 24 key operators and 82 financiers from the market, and acted against depository participants that had opened the accounts.
What changed: in 2007 SEBI made PAN the sole identification number for transactions in the securities market, whatever the amount. That is the root of today's rule that one PAN gets one application in an IPO, and that duplicate applications under one PAN are rejected.
Sources: SEBI order on the Yes Bank IPO, 15 December 2005; SEBI order of 27 April 2006 (24 operators, 82 financiers), as recorded in Karvy Stock Broking vs SEBI, 2 May 2008; SEBI circular on PAN as the sole identification number, 2007. Information only. Not investment advice. Not a SEBI-registered research analyst.